Important Questions to Ask Your Criminal Defense Lawyer Before Hiring Them

Criminal cases are complicated, and the outcome is often uncertain. The stakes are high when you're facing serious criminal charges or a possible conviction. If you've been accused of a crime, it's vital that you have the best legal representation possible. With so many lawyers to choose from, it can take time to decide who is the best lawyer for your unique situation. Before you hire a criminal defense lawyer, you should ask them the following questions:

1. How Much Experience Do You have?

Any lawyer worth their salt will have years of experience successfully handling criminal cases. A good lawyer will have at least five years of experience and a track record of defending clients in the courtroom. The more time a criminal defense lawyer has represented clients, the better they'll be at handling your case. In fact, a good criminal defense lawyer will have several years of trial experience under their belt. They should be able to handle all areas of your case, including arraignment, motions, sentencing, and appellate matters.

2. Is Criminal Law Your Area of Specialty?

A criminal lawyer needs to be familiar with the intricacies of criminal law, and it's important that they have a strong background in helping people in similar situations. They should show you that they know how generic sentencing guidelines work and have a history of helping clients in similar situations get the best outcomes for their cases. You should only hire an attorney if they have extensive experience winning cases like yours and can offer you a reasonable chance of success in court.

3. Does the Lawyer Offer a Free Initial Consultation?

Many attorneys will offer free initial consultations. This is a great opportunity to be able to ask the lawyer questions and understand how they plan to handle your case. Most lawyers won't offer free consultations, but it's still important that you are clear on what you get for the money. Ideally, you're looking for a lawyer who offers an honest and straightforward explanation of their approach and a detailed list of fees and expenses. The fees should be clearly spelled out in a written contract, and the firm should be willing to provide you with all the necessary information in writing.

4. How Accessible Are They?

One of the most important qualities you need in a criminal defense attorney is that they are accessible. They need to be accessible so that you can discuss your options and keep them updated at all times. Your attorney needs to be available by phone, e-mail, text, or face-to-face meetings. You shouldn't have to wait days for phone calls to be returned or delay e-mail responses. You should also know their work hours and whether they're willing to work on weekends and holidays.

5. What strategy do you recommend for my case?

Ask your lawyer what the normal procedure will be for handling your case. It's important that you know how your attorney works and what the process for handling cases like yours will be. They should tell you about how they collect evidence for trial, how their approach is to building a case, and any other information that is helpful to you in making important decisions about your case. By asking questions about their procedures, you can get a better sense of what to expect from them in the future and whether they are likely to be able to help win your case.


6. How Much Does the Attorney Charge?

Knowing how much your lawyer charges for their services is important. Usually, criminal defense lawyers charge either an hourly fee or a contingency fee. The hourly fee means that you pay the lawyer regardless of whether you win the case or not. A contingency fee means that the lawyer will only get paid if you win your case. If you lose, you don't have to pay anything. Ask your potential attorney how much they charge for their services and what their fee structures are.


7. Does the Lawyer Have Offices in My Area?

Having an attorney who has an office in your local area is important. It means they can visit you and handle things on your behalf more easily. You'll want to work with a criminal defense lawyer who is local and who can quickly get to meetings, court dates, etc.


8. What is the Likelihood of Prevailing in a Trial?

You want to be able to talk with your attorney about the likelihood of winning in court. A criminal defense lawyer should know that the chances of winning a case are determined by a number of factors, including the strength of the prosecution's case and the credibility of their witnesses. If a lawyer isn't able to tell you about their approach and the likelihood of prevailing in court, it's best to move on.

9. Do You Handle Cases Like Mine? If yes, what is your success rate?

Ask your attorney how many cases they have handled that are similar to yours. They should be able to give you an idea of how often they handle cases like yours and their success rate in handling those cases in the past. You want to work with a lawyer with a relatively high success rate when it comes to similar cases because that means you will likely receive some positive results as well.


10. Are You a Member of Any Local Bar Associations?

Make sure your attorney is a member of a bar association. This will help to ensure that they are licensed as an attorney and should also give you some reassurance that they are proficient in handling cases like yours. A sign that they are members of a bar will also provide you with a sense of the quality of lawyers in your area. You can also ask to see their bar association registry if you feel uneasy about working with a lawyer who is not a member of any bar association.


11. What Will My Role Be During the Trial?

Ask your attorney whether you will be required to do anything during a trial. A good attorney will always be sure that the client understands their role and what they can expect from the whole process. Some people are uncomfortable speaking in court or dealing with different lawyers who are part of the prosecution team. You should also ask about any possible procedures that may be used during a trial and whether your lawyer will have time to prepare for your case before it comes to court.


12. As My Criminal Defense Attorney, How Often Will We Communicate?

Communication with your attorney is vital to keeping you informed and engaged in the case. The lawyer will explain how they work on cases and what kind of help you can expect as a client. They will also let you know what updates to expect, such as progress reports or other communications.  

Remember that choosing the right criminal defense attorney for your particular case is vital. Working with a lawyer who doesn't know what they're doing could make things worse for you. A good criminal defense attorney will be able to protect your rights and give you the best chance of avoiding long jail sentences and harsh fines. By asking your potential lawyer these questions, you'll have a much better chance of finding an attorney who is able to help you in all aspects of your case.

Disclaimer: This material is provided for informational purposes only. The provision of this material does not create an attorney-client relationship between the firm and the reader and does not constitute legal advice. Legal advice must be tailored to the specific circumstances of each case, and the contents of this newsletter are not a substitute for legal counsel. Do not take action in reliance on the contents of this material without seeking the advice of counsel.

The information contained in this blog may or may not reflect the most current legal developments. Accordingly, information in this blog is not promised or guaranteed to be correct or complete, and should not be relied upon as such. Readers should conduct their own appropriate legal research.

6521 N. 10th Street, Ste. A — McAllen, TX 78504
+1 956 567 7777